Shirley Homes for Sale

Shirley Homes for Sale

Welcome to Shirley, New York – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Suffolk County. This charming community offers an idyllic blend of suburban tranquility and vibrant local culture, making it an ideal place to call home. With its picturesque landscapes, friendly neighborhoods, and convenient access to major highways, Shirley is perfect for families, professionals, and anyone seeking a peaceful retreat.

Shirley boasts an array of outdoor recreational opportunities, with nearby parks and nature reserves that invite you to explore the great outdoors. The stunning beaches of the South Shore are just a short drive away, providing perfect spots for relaxation and fun in the sun. The community is also home to a variety of local shops, restaurants, and entertainment options, ensuring that residents have everything they need right at their fingertips.

When it comes to homes for sale in Shirley, you'll find an impressive selection that caters to diverse lifestyles and budgets. From charming single-family homes with spacious yards to modern townhouses and cozy condos, there’s something for everyone. Many properties feature updated amenities, open floor plans, and beautiful outdoor spaces, making them perfect for entertaining or enjoying quiet evenings at home.

With its welcoming atmosphere, excellent schools, and strong sense of community, Shirley is more than just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. Discover your dream home in this delightful town, where comfort and convenience meet. Explore our listings today and take the first step toward making Shirley your new home!

Newest Shirley Homes for Sale

$550,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1055121 MLS
Welcome to 21 Lisa Court. Set at the end of a dead-end street in North Shirley, this 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath raised ranch sits on a generous three-quarter acre and offers a private, tucked-away setting with easy access to major roadways for commuting. Curb appeal shines with a long private driveway, a manicured front lawn, colorful landscaped garden beds, and a backdrop of mature trees. Step inside to a bright, sun-filled living room with soaring vaulted ceilings, two skylights, gleaming hardwood floors, and a wide bay window with a built-in window seat. A pass-through opening connects the living room to the eat-in kitchen, keeping the main living space open and connected. The kitchen offers ample oak cabinetry, a gas range, a stainless French-door refrigerator, a pantry closet, and wood-look flooring. The dining area has sliding glass doors that open to a deck overlooking the backyard. The primary bedroom has its own full bath with a stall shower. Two more bedrooms share a full hall bath with a tub and shower, and a mix of hardwood and wood-look flooring runs throughout the main level. Ceiling fans throughout keep the main level comfortable year-round. A separate laundry room off the kitchen includes cabinet storage and its own exterior door to the deck, making it a convenient mudroom entry. The full finished lower level with outside entrance adds a generous amount of additional living space, with several flexible rooms for a home office, gym, recreation space, or hobbies. Outside, the expansive, level backyard is a true retreat, with a lush lawn, a deck, a large patio, and a beautiful wooded border for privacy. Two storage sheds and a 1-car garage with an automatic opener, shelving, and a workbench provide plenty of room for tools, equipment, and seasonal storage. With its private setting, spacious lot, and room to add your own personal touches, 21 Lisa Court is a wonderful opportunity in North Shirley.

21 Lisa Court, Shirley

$499,990
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1053750 MLS
Welcome to 38 Heston Road, a beautifully reimagined contemporary Ranch where iconic Mid-Century Modern architectural soul seamlessly meets an Eclectic Retro and Modern Bohemian vibe. Set on a generous 0.36-acre property, this residence offers a warm, character-rich sanctuary designed for creative living, elevated comfort, and effortless entertaining. The main floor features an airy, light-flooded layout anchored by a formal dining room with a striking statement chandelier. The adjacent walk-through kitchen balances organic elegance and sleek functionality, complete with quartz countertops, an electric cooktop, a wall oven/microwave, and quality stainless steel appliances. The main level offers two spacious bedrooms—including a peaceful primary suite with its own full en-suite bath—plus a second full bathroom, providing comfortable single-level living options. The expansive lower level expands your options with a full, partially finished basement that includes a third full bathroom, dedicated laundry space, and private exterior access. Every major component of the home has been thoughtfully modernized between 2019 and 2021, combining retro aesthetics with true peace of mind. Key system upgrades include a new roof, Marvin fiberglass windows, blown-in attic insulation, a new water heater, upgraded 200-amp electrical service with a 100-amp subpanel in the garage, and a complete HVAC system with central air conditioning. Outdoor living is equally refined, featuring a fully vinyl-fenced yard, an 11-zone sprinkler system, a custom patio for alfresco gatherings, a new storage shed, and new garage doors complementing the attached two-car garage. This property offers a vibrant fusion of vintage architectural charm, artistic modern style, and everyday comfort.

38 Heston Road, Shirley

$469,999
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1053238 MLS
Welcome to this beautifully updated Shirley home, set on a double lot in Flood Zone X with taxes under $3,500 and an incredible amount of usable outdoor space. Major exterior updates include a new roof with all plywood replaced (March 2022), new siding and gutters (2022), front and side windows (February 2022), new front porch rafters (2022), and solar panels (2022). The interior offers a comfortable open layout with a spacious living room and dining area, abundant natural light, recessed lighting, and updated LVP flooring completed in October 2025. The kitchen features abundant cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, a center island, and a layout that opens directly into the main living space. A 4-zone mini-split system was installed in 2023/2024, with two zones currently connected and two additional zones available for future use. The basement was remodeled in April 2024, creating additional finished space for a home office, recreation area, gym, or storage. Outside, the property truly shines with a paver patio and dedicated hot tub pad completed in June 2024, hot tub added in August 2024, 12x20 shed added in 2024, full underground irrigation installed in June 2025 with seven zones plus a front-bed mister, new driveway with paver border and retaining wall completed in July 2025, and new sod installed in August 2025. The expansive backyard has been further enhanced with 2026 landscaping, vinyl fencing installed in phases throughout 2025 and 2026, multiple entertaining areas, a fire-pit area, outdoor dining space, and plenty of open lawn, providing an ideal setting for entertaining or enjoying the property year-round. Additional updates include a 2021 hot water heater, 2021 Frigidaire dishwasher, and September 2025 Samsung Bespoke refrigerator. With its oversized lot, extensive updates, finished basement, impressive outdoor setup, and low taxes, this home offers a rare opportunity in Shirley.

154 W End Avenue, Shirley

$549,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1049711 MLS
Welcome to Your Turnkey Coastal Masterpiece in Shirley! Nestled in the heart of Shirley, this fully renovated, 1,500 sq. ft. ranch seamlessly blends modern elegance with effortless everyday living. Step inside to a sun-drenched, open-concept floor plan accented by gorgeous new flooring and premium finishes throughout. The stunning chef’s kitchen serves as the heart of the home, showcasing sophisticated shaker-style cabinetry, luxurious quartz countertops with a matching slab backsplash, and high-efficiency stainless steel appliances. Whether you’re preparing a meal or entertaining guests, this kitchen is designed to impress. The versatile layout features 4 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and a spacious 5th bonus room with endless possibilities. Use it as an additional bedroom, home office, or create a second kitchen for the potential of a mother-daughter-style setup, with proper permits. The bonus room also offers a separate entrance, providing added flexibility and convenience. Enjoy exceptional peace of mind with an extensive list of brand-new upgrades, including a new roof, siding, gutters, plumbing throughout, electric water heater, 200-amp electrical panel, renovated bathrooms, washer and dryer, and a spacious 4-car driveway. Step outside into your private backyard oasis, complete with an expansive patio perfect for summer barbecues, outdoor entertaining, relaxing , or enjoying peaceful evenings under the stars. Conveniently located just minutes from beautiful beaches, the marina, parks, and schools, with easy access to shopping and major roadways, this home combines modern comfort with Shirley’s desirable coastal charm. Additional highlights include low property taxes and no flood insurance requirement. This exceptional turnkey home is ready to welcome its next owners. Schedule your private showing today and experience coastal living at its finest!

58 Appel Drive E, Shirley

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.