Bay Shore Homes for Sale

Bay Shore Homes for Sale

Welcome to Bay Shore, New York—a charming coastal community located in the heart of Suffolk County. Nestled along the picturesque shores of the Great South Bay, Bay Shore is renowned for its stunning waterfront views, vibrant downtown, and rich history. This idyllic town offers a perfect blend of suburban tranquility and urban convenience, making it an ideal place to call home.

Bay Shore boasts a diverse array of homes for sale, catering to a wide range of lifestyles and preferences. From quaint bungalows and historic Victorian houses to modern waterfront condos, there is something for everyone in this charming community. Many properties feature spacious yards, updated interiors, and breathtaking views, making them perfect for families, retirees, or anyone looking to enjoy the beauty of coastal living.

The community is not just about beautiful homes; it also offers a wealth of amenities. Residents can enjoy leisurely strolls along the scenic bayfront, explore local parks, or indulge in the vibrant dining and shopping options in the downtown area. With easy access to the Long Island Rail Road, commuting to New York City is a breeze, allowing you to savor the best of both worlds.

Whether you're a first-time homebuyer or seeking a serene retreat, Bay Shore offers a welcoming atmosphere and a strong sense of community. Discover your dream home in this captivating town and experience the unique charm that Bay Shore has to offer. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to be part of this wonderful community—explore the homes for sale today!

Newest Bay Shore Homes for Sale

$469,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1051700 MLS
Why rent when you can own? This charming, well-maintained 2-bedroom home is move-in ready and full of possibilities! Featuring wood flooring throughout, gas heat and cooking, and newer windows. The kitchen offers plenty of counter space and opens to a spacious dining room, perfect for everyday living and entertaining. The unfinished basement provides additional space with endless possibilities to make it your own. Outside, enjoy a fully fenced yard, in-ground sprinkler system, and storage shed. Additional updates include a hot water heater just 1 year old. Move right in and enjoy as-is, or add your own personal touches and make this home truly yours!

35 Montauk Drive, Bay Shore
$799,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1051105 MLS
Welcome to 72 S. Penataquit Ave. in Bay Shore! This charming three-bedroom ranch is nestled in a beautiful neighborhood south of Montauk Highway and offers comfortable one-level living with plenty of potential. Featuring hardwood floors, a cozy fireplace and a full basement, this inviting home is perfect for a starter family or those looking to downsize. The detached one-car garage provides convenient parking and could easily be transformed into the ultimate man cave, hobby space or private retreat. With its warm character, desirable location and wonderful possibilities, this lovely Bay Shore home is ready to welcome its next owner.

72 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore
$600,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1047860 MLS
This Well-Maintained 4 Bedroom, 2 Full Bath Ranch Offers A Bright Eat-In Kitchen, Hardwood Floors, Central Air, And A Full Unfinished Basement Providing Plenty Of Storage. The Fully Fenced Backyard Features Durable PVC Fencing, Offering Privacy And Outdoor Space To Enjoy.

1528 Baldwin Boulevard, Bay Shore
$499,999
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1045766 MLS
New to the market, this attached home has plenty to offer. Main floor living space offers an open floor layout. Spacious kitchen with large center island opens to living room. Sliders off the living room take you to rear deck and large yard. Second floor has two bedrooms and full bath. Master bedroom has an abundance of closet space. Homeowner designed for optimum usage. Finished basement has laundry, and a large area for Den / Media room, etc. Plenty of room to spread out.

263 N 3rd Avenue, Bay Shore
$548,888
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1050810 MLS
1065 Udall Rd is officially on the market and ready for its next owner. This newly renovated 4-bedroom, 2-bath home also includes a bonus room with an outside separate entrance, giving you the extra space so many buyers are looking for. Whether you need a home office, guest room, playroom, den, or workout space, the layout gives you plenty of flexibility. The home is set across two levels and features dual heating zones for added comfort. Inside, you’ll find updated finishes, stainless steel appliances, plus a washer and dryer already in place. A new roof was installed in 2025, adding another important update to the home. Outside, the property is equipped with in-ground sprinklers to help keep the lawn and landscaping looking their best. The location is another big plus. Situated in the heart of Bay Shore, the home is close to shopping centers, malls, supermarkets, restaurants, major roadways, and everyday conveniences. With four bedrooms, two full baths, bonus space, recent renovations, a 2025 roof, stainless steel appliances, dual heating zones, and a central Bay Shore location, 1065 Udall Rd offers a great combination of space, updates, and convenience. Schedule your private showing with me and come see everything this home has to offer.

1065 Udall Road, Bay Shore
$735,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1050572 MLS
Meet Sue Allen — a beautiful, recently updated 4-bedroom, 2-bath home looking to call her home. ?? ? Inside, you’ll find: • Updated stainless steel appliances • Beautiful granite countertops • A warm and inviting enclosed porch • Spacious bedrooms with room for the whole family • A comfortable layout perfect for everyday living and entertaining ?? Commuters will love the location! Sue Allen is just minutes from the Bay Shore train station, making travel into NYC convenient and easy. ??? You’re also only minutes away from the heart of Downtown Bay Shore, where you can enjoy restaurants, shopping, entertainment, nightlife, and everything this vibrant community has to offer. ?? Sue Allen isn’t just a house — she’s looking to make new memories with.

110 N Park Avenue, Bay Shore
$849,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1049887 MLS
Completely re-built in 2009: of the 1962 structure, one small closet wall, garage and (partial) original basement was kept. An additional foundation was added to create what is now, the current home! The home and property are exceptional. From quiet mornings on the welcoming front porch to relaxed evenings on the rear patio, this is a home designed to be enjoyed. Warm, inviting and thoughtfully remodeled, it blends timeless Colonial character with the comfort, convenience and modern features today’s buyers appreciate. The home is in move right in condition, the location is mid-block, not backing, siding or fronting any busy roads, yet conveniently located to allow easy access in and out of the community. Step inside through the dramatic cathedral entrance foyer, where generous room sizes, hardwood floors throughout and a gracious, flowing layout immediately set the tone. The formal living room or parlor offers a versatile setting for welcoming guests, reading, relaxing, studying or creating an elegant home office. At the heart of the home is the spacious eat-in kitchen, beautifully appointed with granite countertops, Energy Star appliances, gas cooking and a convenient butler’s service area—perfect for casual meals, holiday gatherings and effortless entertaining. A gas burning fireplace adds warmth and character to the inviting living spaces, while the conveniently located first-floor laundry and mudroom with separate outside entrance that also provides access to the basement brings everyday practicality to the home’s thoughtful design. The upper level features four generously sized bedrooms, included, the Primary with a luxurious en-suite, abundant closet space and the storage every home needs. The partially finished basement provides even more room to enjoy, with flexible space for recreation, hobbies, fitness, guests or additional work-from-home needs, additional basement space makes room for whatever your heart desires. A separate side entrance via the mudroom/laundry area allows for convenient access to the basement. The majority of the home was re-built/renovated in 2009. The home features but is not limited to the following; Andersen 400 Series windows, 200-amp electrical service and a French drain system surrounding the home—valuable improvements that enhance comfort, efficiency and peace of mind. Outside, the beautifully maintained and rear fenced property creates a wonderful private setting for relaxing, entertaining, gardening and enjoying the seasons. The front porch, rear patio and attractive grounds extend the living experience well beyond the interior. Ideally located minutes to Bay Shore’s vibrant Main Street, exceptional dining, cafes, shopping, the Great South Bay waterfront, Fire Island ferries, parks, beaches, the Long Island Railroad and major roadways, this home offers an appealing combination of neighborhood charm and everyday convenience. First time offered and an unbelievable value—this exceptional, beautifully designed Colonial is ready to welcome its next owner. Move right in, settle in and make it yours. First showing - full weekend, allowing all that are truly serious and interested to visit and envision yourself in this home.

1456 Pine Acres Boulevard, Bay Shore
$619,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1049627 MLS
Welcome to this beautifully renovated 4-bedroom, 2-bath ranch offering comfortable one-level living. This move-in-ready home features updated finishes throughout, a spacious and functional layout, and plenty of room for everyday living and entertaining. A detached garage provides additional storage and parking. Conveniently located with easy access to major roadways, shopping, dining, and everyday amenities, this home combines modern updates with an ideal location.

1340 Manor Lane, Bay Shore
$749,999
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1048658 MLS
Looking for a true "move in ready" Hi-Ranch in the heart of Bayshore in Islip School District in close proximity to all of the amenities you could wish for including but not limited to; public transportation, restaurants, parks, marinas and much much more? Ok great! Welcome to this beautifully updated 1,750 sq. ft. home offering a flexible layout and an abundance of recent improvements! The main level features an inviting open-concept living room and kitchen equipped with gas cooking and new stainless steel appliances, high ceilings, wainscoting, an updated full bathroom and two bedrooms. The lower level offers additional versatile living space with a two separate entrances offering immense privacy and the potential for extended family or rental income with proper permits. Featuring a one-bedroom layout with a kitchen and living room combination and a full bathroom with an outside entrance. There is also an additional studio-style space with its own separate entrance, offering the potential for a fourth bedroom, guest space, home office, or additional living area and another full bathroom. The home includes a dedicated laundry room with new tile and a stackable washer and dryer, and utilities. Recent updates include a newer roof, new forced-hot-air heating system, new mini-split AC system, new deck, fresh interior and exterior paint, new foyer tile, and refinished wood floors. With 4 bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, and multiple flexible living spaces, this home offers exceptional versatility and plenty of room to make it your own! Enjoy the curb appeal and blank canvass of a yard equipped with in-ground sprinklers being the "cherry on top" of this beautiful listing! Do not miss 1527 St Louis Avenue, Bayshore! LOW TAXES W/ BASIC STAR (Islip School District) & PUBLIC SEWERS!!!!

1527 Saint Louis Avenue, Bay Shore
$520,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1025795 MLS
Welcome to this 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom Ranch with 1,710 square feet of one level living. It offers hardwood floors an updated kitchen with quartz counters and stainless appliances. The primary suite features its own private full bathroom, and two additional spacious bedrooms, a dedicated laundry room with plenty of storage, updated vinyl siding and windows (2023) and an attached garage with an electric opener. Outside enjoy a fully fenced backyard with in ground sprinkler system and covered front porch. This home is move in ready!

15 Center Avenue, Bay Shore
$680,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1047846 MLS
Move in ready home in Bay Shore with custom upgrades galore! Kept in the family since it was built, this spacious 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom hi-ranch also offers a partial basement to make your own. The upper level features 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, including a primary ensuite, plus a bright family room. Downstairs offers a living room with maple hardwood flooring, two flexible office/den spaces, an updated kitchen with stainless steel appliances, and a beautiful dining room. Additional updates include vinyl siding with shake accents on the front, a top-of-the-line Roth oil tank, and a generator-ready hookup for added convenience. The roof and driveway seal, were also completed within approx. the last ten years. Outside, enjoy your own private oasis lined with trees for added privacy, a lush well-maintained vegetable garden, in-ground sprinklers, and newer fencing. Centrally located near shopping centers and a local brewery, this home is just minutes from major highways, major beaches, fire Island ferry, and Bay Shore's Main Street - all within minutes away!

35 Jensen Road, Bay Shore
$689,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1048032 MLS
Welcome Home! step into this beautifully updated residence where comfort meets style, it offers 4Br, 3Bth a full finished basement with outside separate entrance, this property is conveniently located close to all shopping and major highways, Don't miss this opportunity, New Cesspool, windows, roof, siding, front entrance too much to list many updates a must see!!!

1085 Bay Shore Avenue, Bay Shore
Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.