Muttontown Homes for Sale

Welcome to Muttontown, New York, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Nassau County. Known for its picturesque landscapes and serene atmosphere, Muttontown offers a unique blend of suburban tranquility and easy access to the vibrant life of Long Island. With sprawling estates, lush greenery, and a strong sense of community, this charming village is the perfect place for families, retirees, and anyone looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life.

Muttontown is steeped in history, featuring beautiful parks and nature reserves that invite you to explore the great outdoors. The area boasts some of the most prestigious schools in the state, making it an ideal location for families seeking quality education for their children. With its rich heritage and commitment to preserving green spaces, Muttontown provides a peaceful sanctuary while still being conveniently located near major highways and public transportation options.

For those considering a move, Muttontown offers an impressive selection of homes for sale. From luxurious estates with sprawling grounds to charming single-family homes, there’s something for everyone. Each property reflects the unique character of the area, featuring stunning architecture, modern amenities, and beautifully landscaped yards. Whether you’re seeking a cozy retreat or an expansive family home, Muttontown’s real estate market has options that cater to every lifestyle and budget.

Discover the allure of Muttontown, where community spirit and natural beauty come together to create an idyllic living experience. Explore our listings today and find your dream home in this enchanting village!

Newest Muttontown Homes for Sale

$2,495,000

6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1028493 MLS

Welcome to Lion Crest, an established community in one of Muttontown's most desirable locations within the highly acclaimed Jericho School District. Set on a private half-acre surrounded by mature landscaping, this expanded ranch offers the perfect balance of generous living space, comfort, and everyday elegance. Designed with both functionality and flexibility in mind, the home features six bedrooms, four full bathrooms, and a powder room. The main level offers five bedrooms, three full baths and one half bath, ideal for guests or multigenerational living. Upstairs, spacious oversized bedroom suite with an updated full bath and walk in closet to accommodate every lifestyle. The fully finished basement provides exceptional space for recreation, fitness, hobbies, or storage. Outdoors, a beautifully landscaped backyard creates a peaceful retreat, complete with a heated Gunite in-ground pool and patio—perfect for relaxing, entertaining, and enjoying the privacy of the setting. Additional highlights include natural gas heating and cooking, central air conditioning, complete new roof 2024, all hardscape in patio completed 2022, freshly painted exterior 2026 and thoughtfully maintained interiors throughout. Combining a sought-after Muttontown location, the prestigious Jericho School District, and a versatile floor plan, this is a home designed for comfortable living and memorable gatherings. Community Tennis Court, Community Pickleball Court.

70 Karol Place, Muttontown

$5,599,000

6 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ 1026409 MLS

Introducing an Extraordinary new Construction Estate in the prestigious Village of Muttontown, Set on approximately 3 Private acres overlooking a Picturesque Golf Couse. This Exceptional 2026 built residence offers the perfect blend of Modern Luxury , Elegance, and Sophistication. Featuring Six (6) Spacious Bedrooms and 6.5 designer bathrooms, with Radiant Heated Floors. The home showcases impeccable craftsmanship and high-end finishes throughout. A Grand Entrance welcomes you into a breathtaking Great Room, with soring ceilings, expansive windows, and abundant natural light, creating an impressive setting for both everyday living and entertaining. Designed for comfort and style, the residence includes two fireplaces- One Gas and One Electric, adding warmth and ambiance to the home's thoughtfully designed living spaces. The open and flowing floor plan seamlessly connects formal and informal areas while maximizing the stunning Golf Course Views. Nestled on a beautifully situated 3-acre property, this Magnificent estate offers privacy, tranquility, and resort style living in one of Long Island's most sought after communities. A rare opportunity to own a newly built luxury home in the Heart of Muttontown.

730 Remsens Lane, Muttontown

$2,995,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1019700 MLS

Welcome to this renovated 5 Bedroom, 4.5 Bath Colonial set on 2 beautifully landscaped acres, a truly move-in ready home. Located on the North Side of Northern Blvd/25A bordering Upper Brookville. The chef’s kitchen is appointed with Carrara Marble countertops, premium Wolf and Sub-Zero appliances, and high-end finishes. The elegant living room offers custom built-ins accented by Imperial Danby marble, beautifully complemented by a gas fireplace. Every bathroom has been meticulously renovated with designer materials and fixtures. The hall bath showcases Carrara and Dolomite marble complemented by a custom vanity, while the primary suite offers a spa-inspired bath finished with Calacatta Gold marble and Waterworks fixtures. Outside, a sprawling Bluestone patio with 2 retractable awnings serve as the centerpiece for exceptional outdoor entertaining, complete with a fully equipped outdoor kitchen featuring a DCS gas grill, Lynx pizza oven, refrigerator, ice maker, and warming drawer. The other side of the patio is complete with an outdoor gas fireplace and TV. Beyond, a spectacular saltwater Gunite Pool with a gas heater and waterfall. Full House Generator. Low taxes! Pre-approval letter or proof of funds is required prior to confirming all showings.

855 Orchard Lane, Muttontown

$3,995,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1018900 MLS

There are homes that simply offer space, and there are homes that define a lifestyle. Perfectly positioned on almost two secluded acres within the Incorporated Village of Muttontown and served by the highly acclaimed Syosset School District, this exceptional Hamptons-inspired estate represents a rare opportunity to enjoy timeless architecture, modern technology, and effortless luxury in one of Long Island's most prestigious settings. Encompassing approximately 7,000 square feet, this five-bedroom, five-and-a-half-bath residence has been comprehensively reimagined from top to bottom. Every major component—from the electrical and mechanical systems to the roof, windows, and finishes—has been thoughtfully updated, creating a home that offers the confidence of new construction while preserving the warmth, character and durability that is lacking in todays new builds. Designed with today's lifestyle in mind, the interiors are equally suited for intimate evenings or grand-scale entertaining. Sunlit living spaces flow seamlessly from one room to the next, anchored by four fireplaces that add warmth and sophistication throughout. At the heart of the home is a showpiece chef's kitchen, crafted to inspire everyone from the accomplished home cook to the most discerning culinary enthusiast. A recent expansion rivals the finest of private clubs, featuring a state-of-the-art home theater with a custom bar, a dedicated fitness studio, and flexible recreation space designed for every generation. Outside, resort-style living unfolds across meticulously landscaped grounds. The heated saltwater pool with an expansive sun shelf invites relaxed afternoons, while the pavilion, outdoor kitchen, and multiple entertaining areas create the perfect setting for everything from summer gatherings to elegant evening celebrations. Integrated smart-home technology places lighting, climate, and audio, at your fingertips, delivering a level of convenience that complements today's connected lifestyle. For collectors and automotive enthusiasts, the heated four-car garage features soaring ceilings designed to accommodate vehicle lifts, offering exceptional flexibility for additional cars or a hobby space. Whether you're seeking room to grow, looking for a peaceful retreat with an easy commute to Manhattan, or searching for an elegant home where holidays become traditions and every visit feels like a destination, this remarkable estate offers the rare combination of privacy, sophistication, and enduring value. This is more than a residence—it's the home everyone will want to come back to.

192 Burtis Lane, Muttontown

$3,650,000

4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1016622 MLS

Experience refined luxury in the exclusive gated community of Stone Hill, where exceptional craftsmanship, resort-style amenities, and carefree living come together in one of Muttontown's most sought-after private enclaves. Set on over ¾ of an acre, this beautifully designed 5,000-square-foot residence offers 4 bedrooms+, 4.5 baths, and an impeccable blend of timeless elegance and modern comfort. A dramatic double-height foyer opens to a breathtaking great room with soaring ceilings, a wall of floor-to-ceiling windows, custom millwork, built-ins, and a striking double-sided stone gas fireplace. The chef's kitchen is beautifully appointed with premium appliances, custom cabinetry, an oversized center island, separate pantry, and architectural detailing, while the elegant dining room with a coffered ceiling is ideal for entertaining. The main-level primary suite offers a luxurious retreat with a spa-inspired bath featuring a Jacuzzi, sauna, double-sided gas fireplace, and oversized closet. Two additional bedrooms complete the first floor, while the second level offers a fourth bedroom and spacious bonus room. The expansive finished lower level with 10-foot ceilings and outside entrance provides abundant space for recreation, fitness, or entertaining. Outside, the private backyard offers ample room for a pool and the ultimate outdoor retreat. Additional highlights include radiant heated floors throughout, wide-plank hardwood floors, whole-house generator, whole-house water filtration system, central vacuum, and fine custom finishes throughout. Residents enjoy 24-hour gated security, a full-service clubhouse with an indoor pool, fitness center, tennis courts, and social room, along with lawn care and snow removal through the HOA. Located in the award-winning Syosset School District, this home offers an unparalleled lifestyle in one of Long Island's premier private communities.

5 Buckingham Court, Muttontown

$3,739,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1016504 MLS

Welcome to an extraordinary Shingle Style Colonial set on 2.37 pristine, bucolic acres in the Incorporated Village of Muttontown. A stately approach begins at a gated entry set back from the road, where stone piers, ironwork and low landscape lighting create a sense of arrival. Beyond the gate a long driveway stretches forward in a clean deliberate line framed on both sides by a formal allee of mature trees. This 4-bedroom, 3-bath residence has been impeccably reimagined for modern luxury living. A full-scale remodel in 2022 was followed by a seamless 1400-square-foot extension and extensive outdoor enhancements completed between 2023 and 2026, resulting in a home that feels both timeless and entirely turnkey. Every detail has been thoughtfully curated with an elevated eye for design, craftsmanship, and comfort. The custom eat-in chef's kitchen is a true showpiece, appointed with paneled Thermador appliances, a professional-grade range and ovens, Miele steam oven and coffee maker, brass fixtures, quartz countertops, and exquisite designer finishes. Designed for both intimate everyday living and gracious entertaining, the spectacular great room features 9-foot ceilings with coffered detail, a gas fireplace and French doors to the patio and rear grounds. Just off the kitchen, the sun-filled living rooms offer an additional gas fireplace and a warm, elegant atmosphere, creating a beautiful flow throughout the main level. Completing the first floor is a bedroom or private office, full bath and mudroom with direct access to the magnificent backyard retreat. Upstairs, the primary ensuite is a serene and sophisticated sanctuary, featuring vaulted ceilings, refined marble and brass finishes, an oversized cast stone soaking tub, and a luxurious dual thermostatic shower. Adjoining the primary suite is a stunning gym or bonus room with cathedral ceilings and abundant natural light, offering the perfect space for wellness, work, or relaxation. Two additional bedrooms share a beautifully appointed full bath, and each bedroom features custom closets, complemented by a linen closet for added storage. A convenient laundry room is located off the primary suite. The grounds are equally impressive, offering a private, resort-like setting with estate-quality landscaping surrounding the residence and cottage, while beautifully framing the patios, walkways, and outdoor living spaces. A 37-zone digital irrigation system keeps the property lush and pristine, enhancing the natural beauty of the acreage throughout the seasons. Thoughtfully designed with both elegance and efficiency in mind, the home features abundant natural light, wide-plank white oak floors, hydronic heating, central vacuum, alarm system, exterior Ring cameras, Sonos sound system, generator and numerous energy-efficient upgrades throughout. A rare and remarkable offering in one of Muttontown's most beautiful settings, this exceptional turnkey residence blends classic Shingle Style architecture with sophisticated modern luxury, exquisite finishes, thoughtful design, and extraordinary detail - all with low taxes $25,492 and located within the Jericho School District.

1920 Midlane, Muttontown

$3,890,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1016748 MLS

Top Syosset School District, Don't miss this wonderful better than new 5-bedroom home located in the gated community of Stone Hill Muttontown. Nestled within an exclusive private HOA community, zoned for pool,24 hour security, club house, indoor pool, tennis, lawn and snow removal. this luxurious estate provides the perfect blend of privacy, and modern comfort. Set on a sprawling 1.33 acre lot of elevated terrain, the home commands a stately presence with over 6661 square feet of refined living space. Upon entering, guests are greeted by soaring high ceilings that enhance the sense of openness and light throughout the home. Architectural details such as custom millwork, and expansive windows add sophistication and warmth to each room. The residence features 5 spacious bedrooms and 5.5 elegantly appointed bathrooms, each designed with high-end finishes, natural stone, and designer fixtures. The primary suite is a sanctuary of its own, complete with a sitting area, spa-inspired en-suite bath, and oversized walk-in closets. Living spaces are ideal for both entertaining and everyday luxury, including formal and casual living and dining areas, a chef’s kitchen with top-tier appliances and custom cabinetry, and a private home office. Outdoor living is just as impressive: lush landscaping surrounds the property, providing both beauty and seclusion. The elevated setting offers serene views and excellent drainage. There's ample space for a fish pond, outdoor kitchen, and garden retreats—perfect for enjoying the temperate climate in complete privacy. Backyard with BBQ area.

5 Westgate Road, Muttontown

$7,995,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1013521 MLS

MUTTONTOWN. Set on nearly four private acres directly across from the renowned Muttontown Preserve, this recently built architectural masterpiece masterfully captures the timeless grandeur of Long Island's Gold Coast while embracing the sophistication and conveniences of modern luxury living. Constructed by one of the North Shore and Hamptons' premier luxury builders, this exceptional stone and stucco estate showcases unparalleled craftsmanship, exquisite finishes, and resort-style amenities throughout. Approached by impeccably landscaped grounds featuring rolling lawns, mature specimen trees, vibrant gardens, three cascading waterfalls, and complete privacy fencing, the residence offers a truly breathtaking setting. Four porches, a wraparound patio, and a fully equipped outdoor kitchen create seamless indoor-outdoor living and entertaining spaces. Inside, a sun-drenched two-story foyer introduces soaring ceilings, elegant architectural details, and refined finishes at every turn. The home offers five spacious bedrooms, including luxurious primary suites on both the first and second levels, along with four full and one half baths. Exquisite features include extensive custom millwork, 18-inch crown moldings, mosaic-inlaid stone flooring, designer lighting, custom built-ins, radiant heat, and multiple gas fireplaces that create warmth and ambiance throughout the home. The gourmet chef's kitchen blends modern Tuscan-inspired design with top-tier functionality, featuring Wolf and Sub-Zero appliances, an oversized center island, beverage station, walk-in pantry, and sunlit breakfast area overlooking the grounds. A banquet-sized dining room highlighted by a dramatic contemporary fireplace provides the perfect setting for elegant entertaining, while the private home office offers a peaceful retreat with picturesque garden views. The first-floor primary suite serves as an ideal guest or owner’s retreat, while the spectacular second-floor primary suite rivals a luxury resort, complete with a private balcony, sitting area, custom fireplace, expansive walk-in closet, and spa-inspired bath featuring a soaking tub, dual vanities, and steam shower. Four additional bedrooms, a bonus suite, and a second laundry room complete the upper level. Additional amenities include dual laundry rooms, a three-car garage, whole-house water filtration system, smart home technology with Lutron lighting and motorized shades, advanced security system, central air conditioning, radiant and forced-air heating, 600-amp electric service, natural gas generator, sound-insulated windows, and a partially finished lower level offering endless possibilities for customization. Conveniently located approximately 30 miles from Manhattan and moments from major transportation, beaches, golf courses, marinas, equestrian facilities, fine dining, and shopping, this extraordinary estate presents a rare opportunity to own a private Gold Coast retreat where timeless elegance, modern luxury, and exceptional craftsmanship come together in perfect harmony.

1782 Route 106, Muttontown

$3,998,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1013615 MLS

Best value and privacy providing easy access to highways, shopping and trains. With soaring ceilings, abundant sunshine and modern updates throughout, you will fall in love at the front door of this chic Muttontown residence located in the Jericho school district. This custom home is ideal for large scale entertaining both inside and out. It offers all the space and privacy you have been dreaming about in a prime Muttontown location. The first floor includes a grand entrance, large living and dining rooms, a family room with fireplace, massive chef's kitchen, primary suite with new knockout closet and bathroom, an additional bedroom and bathroom, stunning new powder room, laundry and outfitted 3 car garage. On the second floor, there are 3 additional spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms plus recreation space. The lower level has outside access and provides recreation space, a generous guest suite with large windows and abundant storage. Set on over 2.3 acres of lush property with an inground pool and hot tub, this is the lifestyle that makes every day a vacation. Tucked away at the end of a cul de sac, yet minutes from everything, 91 Woodhollow Court offers the finest North Shore living.

91 Woodhollow Court, Muttontown

$5,888,000

6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1001932 MLS

Discover unparalleled luxury in the heart of Muttontown at 2 Chelmsford Drive, a striking post-modern custom-designed new construction set on a breathtaking 2-acre country club setting. Surrounded by specimen plantings and professionally curated landscaping, this extraordinary estate offers exceptional craftsmanship, sophisticated design, and resort-style amenities throughout. A dramatic custom pivot front door opens to a grand paneled foyer with soaring ceilings ranging from 14 to 20 feet, creating an impressive first impression. Wide-plank white oak floors and custom Pella windows enhance the home's warm, contemporary elegance. The state-of-the-art chef’s kitchen is a true showpiece, featuring rich walnut cabinetry, stunning black quartzite countertops, and a full suite of premium Wolf appliances, including double ovens, a six-burner cook top with griddle, microwave, built-in coffee system, separate ice maker, beverage refrigerator drawers and subzero refrigerator. The formal dining room offers soaring ceilings and walls of glass that open to an outdoor entertaining terrace complete with a full kitchen, pizza oven, and fireplace. The spectacular living room features a double-sided gas fireplace and a custom plaster ceiling. The luxurious primary suite boasts a dramatic 20-foot ceiling, built-in designer headboard feature wall, private deck overlooking the expansive grounds, two custom walk-in closets, and a designer spa bath. Three additional bedrooms are conveniently located on the main level. A stunning illuminated floating staircase leads to the lower level, where you will find additional guest bedrooms, a private gym with adjoining sauna and bath, a large movie theater, and an oversized recreation room with wet bar and glass doors opening directly to the backyard oasis. Designed for ultimate outdoor enjoyment, the country club-inspired grounds feature an oversized heated saltwater Gunite pool with spa, an elegant cabana with outdoor kitchen, and a separate pool house for storage. Automobile enthusiasts will appreciate the extraordinary garage capacity for up to 10 vehicles, including two car lifts, along with a circular paved driveway that completes this one-of-a-kind estate. 2 Chelmsford Drive is a masterfully designed residence that seamlessly blends architectural excellence, luxury amenities, and unparalleled lifestyle living.

2 Chelmsford Drive, Muttontown

$3,488,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1004056 MLS

Exceptional 2009 Custom built Colonial set on a flat 2.4-acre property in the Syosset School District. Designed with timeless curb appeal, this stucco and brick residence offers a bright, open layout with floor-to-ceiling windows, generous natural light, and elegant architectural detail throughout. 10 foot ceiling height on the main level, 9 foot ceiling on second floor. The home features a desirable main-level primary suite wing, offering privacy, comfort, and convenience. Two walk-in closets and a luxurious spa-like bath. An additional office on the main level with front to back fireplace and french doors to sweeping outdoor veranda, provides the perfect space for working from home, a library, or flexible guest space. Formal Living room with walls of glass, front to back fireplace, Formal dining room, powder room, gourmet chef's kitchen with gas cooking, breakfast nook, and family room. First floor also features a mudroom and pantry and access to 3 car garage. Second floor features an additional ensuite bedroom with balcony overlooking 2.4 acre park-like property and full bath. Additional 2 bedrooms with bathroom. Access to large attic space that can be finished for bonus room. Additional highlights include a 3-car garage, radiant heat in bathrooms, a heated circular driveway, and an expansive unfinished basement with 10-foot ceilings, offering incredible potential for future living, recreation, gym, theater, or storage space. Gas heat, gas cooking. A rare combination of acreage, luxury, location, and flexibility — all within the sought-after Syosset School District.

1960 Midlane S, Muttontown

$1,580,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1002874 MLS

Located in one of the most desirable neighborhoods of Muttontown and within the award-winning Jericho School District, this well-maintained residence offers approximately 2,400 square feet of comfortable living space not include the fully finished basement. Upon arrival, you are welcomed by a circular driveway surrounded by mature landscaping, creating both privacy and a beautiful natural setting. Thoughtfully designed for everyday living, the home features 4 spacious bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and 2 half bathrooms, along with the convenience of a main-level laundry room. The fully finished basement offers excellent ceiling height and includes a powder room, cedar closet, gas boiler room and a newly added egress window, providing valuable additional living space with endless possibilities for a recreation room, home office, gym, media room, or guest accommodations. Enjoy the tranquility of suburban living while remaining just minutes from shopping, dining, parks, schools and major Highways. Additional highlights include a 2-year-old roof, classic cedar plank siding, exceptionally low taxes (including village taxes), access to community tennis courts, and the added benefit of the Village of Muttontown's private police force. A rare opportunity to own in the prestigious Lion's Crest section of Muttontown, where privacy, low taxes, village amenities, and the award-winning Jericho School District come together to create an exceptional lifestyle.

18 Kristi Drive, Muttontown

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.